Stop Police Carding in Edmonton
A loud message for the justice minister
Edmonton was the last stop on an Alberta tour for carding activist, and journalist, Desmond Cole. You can see more about the evening on the Twitter hashtag #stopcarding.
Panel discussion kicking off right now. Spirit River Striped Wolf is talking about his negative experiences with police. #stopCarding pic.twitter.com/d4lAizMo5p
— Progress Alberta (@ProgressAlberta) July 14, 2017
Cole was in Calgary and Lethbridge last week as part of a campaign with Progress Alberta to stop police carding in Alberta.
100 concerned Lethbridge citizens out to hear @DesmondCole & panelists talk about #carding — and how to stop it #ableg #yql pic.twitter.com/WOlhkkSrSN
— Progress Alberta (@ProgressAlberta) July 13, 2017
In Edmonton, Black Lives Matter released analysis of carding numbers from the Edmonton Police Service (EPS) over the last five years.
‘Now we have proof’: Data shows Edmonton police disproportionately stop Indigenous and black people https://t.co/5xrGAqkg28 #yeg pic.twitter.com/fyX2JvOoFh
— Metro Edmonton (@metroedmonton) June 28, 2017
CBC Edmonton did a separate review of carding data too, focused on 2016.
Indigenous women nearly 10 x more likely to be street checked by Edmonton police, says new data #carding #Yeg #ableg https://t.co/8gGTIL2x9l pic.twitter.com/rMX4OrxNfu
— Andrea Huncar CBC (@andreahuncar) June 27, 2017
Hundreds turned out to hear more about the issue. As Cole explained, police carding is when officers stop someone who is not suspected of any crime and ask them for their ID and other personal information. This all goes on file in a police database, possibly forever.
Folks gathering to discuss the racist practice of Carding in #yeg #StopCarding pic.twitter.com/j4viaudmMk
— Reakash Walters (@Reakash) July 16, 2017
Cole spoke about our country’s long history of racism, particularly in crime and policing, and targeting people of colour in public.
“Carding is a manifestation of systematic racism. It’s part of the bigger picture of Canada’s colonial history.” –@DesmondCole #StopCarding
— Sharon Mvundura (@sharonmvu) July 16, 2017
If people in #yeg valued the lived experience of POC they wouldn’t need a FOIP request to prove it. Honour the stories. #stopcarding
— Kate Kerber (@katekerber) July 16, 2017
Cole was joined by Tanya Harnett and April Eve Wiberg for a panel discussion. Wiberg shared her own story of being carded and talked about the need for trust in the relationship with police.
“A core value of all of these movements is relationships.” says April Eve, founder of Stolen Sisters Awareness Movement #MMIW #StopCarding pic.twitter.com/eJEUaHES8k
— Reakash Walters (@Reakash) July 16, 2017
Harnett talked about a different kind of carding as systemic racism, showing her Status card as proof she is a “ward of the state”.
#stopCarding panelist Tanya Harnett: “How bad is racism? Take a look at my Indian status card, it says we’re wards of the state.” pic.twitter.com/l3dF7MdyKB
— Keren (@kerentangyeg) July 16, 2017
The audience Q & A became more of a shared story. People in the room talked about when they had been carded. One talked about how police, government and the justice system round people up into “pockets”, like particular housing developments, to make it easier to police them. There were examples of how difficult it is to walk down the street without fear of police. And how an Indigenous person homeless on the street is one who has shouldered the most difficult burdens of a genocide.
The gift of tonight is the space for those with lived experience of carding and systemic racism to be heard and we all listen! #stopcarding
— Maigan vanderGiessen (@tzadekavoice) July 16, 2017
Cole was surprised there were many more stories to questions, but he spoke of being honored that people would take this space to do. It was clear this was a night where people felt safe to share, and, perhaps hope others in the room would not only hear them but take the lessons with them beyond the event to help challenge systemic racism.
#stopCarding “I’m afraid to tell my son his rights, because I’m afraid if he excercises them he could get hurt” -Indigenous lawyer
— Holly Dionne (@Holly_Dionne) July 16, 2017
There were so many people who wanted to speak that the room’s rental time loomed and couldn’t allow everyone a chance to share. “Time is a colonial construct,” event organizer Reakash Walters joked as she brought things to the final part of the night.
Cole phoned up Alberta’s Justice Minister and Solicitor General, Kathleen Ganley, and the packed room left her a voicemail.
Message to the AB Justice Minister. #stopCarding No buts, no review. Abolish carding. pic.twitter.com/8gyORksk9G
— Ubaka Ogbogu (@UbakaOgbogu) July 16, 2017
Where to go next
For people who want to get involved in stopping police carding, getting in touch with your political representatives is a good next step. That could included you current Edmonton city councillors, the candidates who come to your door asking for your vote in October, and your MLA. Both the provincial government and the Edmonton Police Commission are reviewing police street checks and carding, so sharing your opinion with your representatives right now is important.
.@edmontonpolice no one wants your review, no one wants your third party, we demand to live in freedom—stop carding https://t.co/WDfLqEdLPQ
— Desmond Cole (@DesmondCole) July 12, 2017
You can also follow Black Lives Matter-Edmonton and the Stolen Sisters and Brothers Awareness Movement to see what they may be planning next to help put pressure on politicians and police to end this form of racial profiling.
There’s also a documentary about Cole’s work on a book about these same issues of racism.
And if you’re looking for more information on this issue in Edmonton before getting involved, you can see everything that’s been going on at our post on carding. It’s got links to stories, background, the data investigations and should be able to help start you on the way to knowing more about carding and where to get involved.
If you enjoyed this story, and want to see more like it, consider supporting us.
Support EQ